A GST show cause notice that arrives late is not necessarily a notice that has arrived too late. Under Section 74 of the CGST Act the department gets a longer window than under Section 73, but only if it can show fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. That condition is where a large number of notices for older years are weakest. This note explains how the two sections differ, how Section 74A has changed the position from FY 2024-25, and how to test whether the extended period has been properly invoked in your notice.
The two sections, side by side
For periods up to FY 2023-24, the department chooses between two routes for recovering tax short paid, credit wrongly taken or refunds wrongly granted.
| Section 73 | Section 74 | |
|---|---|---|
| When it applies | Any reason other than fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression | Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax |
| Order must be passed within | 3 years from the due date of the annual return for that year | 5 years from the due date of the annual return for that year |
| Notice must be issued at least | 3 months before that deadline | 6 months before that deadline |
| Penalty | 10% of tax or ₹10,000, whichever is higher | Equal to the tax (100%) |
| Pay within 30 days of notice | No penalty | Penalty reduced to 25% |
Take FY 2023-24 as an example. The annual return was due on 31 December 2024. Under Section 73, the notice has to be issued by 30 September 2027 and the order passed by 31 December 2027. Under Section 74, the notice can come as late as 30 June 2029. That gap of almost two years is the reason Section 74 gets invoked in cases where the facts do not really support it.
What changed with Section 74A
Section 74A, inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 and brought into force from 1 November 2024, applies to demands for FY 2024-25 onwards. Sections 73 and 74 continue to govern earlier years.
Under Section 74A there is a single time limit for every case, fraud or not. The notice must be issued within 42 months from the due date of the annual return, and the order within 12 months of the notice, extendable by up to six months. For FY 2024-25, with the annual return due on 31 December 2025, the last date for a notice is 30 June 2029.
The fraud distinction has not disappeared. It has moved. Under Section 74A, the allegation of fraud no longer decides the time limit, but it still decides the penalty: 10% of tax or ₹10,000 for non-fraud cases, against 100% where fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression is alleged, with reduced rates for early payment. For non-fraud cases, paying tax and interest within 60 days of the notice closes the matter without penalty.
One consequence that is already producing results in court: for FY 2024-25 onwards, a notice or order issued under the old Section 73 or 74 is issued under the wrong provision. The Madras High Court has set aside orders passed under Section 74 for FY 2024-25 for exactly this reason, and other courts have quashed such notices with liberty to the department to issue a fresh one under Section 74A, within time. Check the section quoted in any notice for FY 2024-25 or later.
So for older years, contesting the fraud allegation can kill the entire demand on limitation. For FY 2024-25 onwards, the same argument mainly reduces the penalty from 100% to 10%. Both are worth fighting for, but the stakes differ and the reply should be weighted accordingly.
How the department justifies Section 74
In the notices we see, the extended period is usually justified in one of three ways.
Boilerplate. A paragraph stating that the taxpayer “suppressed the facts with intent to evade tax”, with nothing behind it. No specific act, document or omission is identified. This is the easiest to answer.
Data mismatch treated as suppression. The department compares GSTR-1 with GSTR-3B, or GSTR-3B with GSTR-2A or 2B, finds a difference, and calls it suppression. The problem with this approach is that the data came from the taxpayer’s own returns, filed on the department’s own portal. Information that the department had all along is difficult to describe as suppressed. Explanation 2 to Section 74 does define suppression to include non-declaration of facts that were required to be declared in a return, and the department leans heavily on that. The answer depends on whether the fact was in fact declared somewhere the department could see it.
Third-party findings. A supplier is found to be non-existent, and every recipient gets a Section 74 notice on the theory that they knowingly took fake credit. Here the question is what evidence the notice actually offers against you, as opposed to against the supplier.
What the Supreme Court and CBIC have said in 2026
Two developments this year have made the extended period much harder to invoke casually.
In August 2026, the Supreme Court set aside a Section 74 notice for FY 2018-19 because it contained only a bland statement of fraud and suppression, with no facts behind it. The Court held that a notice seeking the extended period must itself disclose the facts on which the allegation rests. It has since set aside another Section 74 notice, and the order passed on it, for the same defect. High Courts have applied the same reasoning, and have rejected the view that an audit objection by itself is enough to justify Section 74.
On 26 October 2026, CBIC issued Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST, following the 57th GST Council meeting. It sets out what a show cause notice must contain and how adjudication and first appeals are to be conducted. Among other things, it tells officers that merely repeating the words fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression is not enough: the notice must state the facts that led to the allegation. It also says an order cannot travel beyond the notice or confirm a demand on grounds never put to the taxpayer, and it reminds officers of the pre-notice intimation in Form DRC-01A, which in many offices had been skipped. A circular does not change the Act, but it is binding on CGST officers and is a useful document to place before them.
Separately, CBIC Instruction No. 02/2026-GST, issued on 30 October 2026, directs CGST officers not to issue show cause notices where the amount involved is below ₹10,000, pending a change in the law. State GST offices follow their own instructions on this.
Testing your notice
When a Section 74 notice comes in for an older year, these are the questions we work through:
- Would the notice be in time under Section 73? If yes, the fraud allegation still matters for penalty, but limitation is not in play. If no, the notice survives only if Section 74 is properly invoked, and the reply should lead with that.
- What specific act or omission is alleged? Look for a fact, not an adjective. “Wilful” and “intent” are conclusions. The notice should say what was concealed, from whom, and how. After the Supreme Court’s August 2026 rulings and Circular 258, a notice that does not do this is open to challenge on that ground alone.
- Was the information already with the department? If the discrepancy appears from returns, e-way bills or e-invoices filed on the portal, say so, and show where.
- Is it a question of interpretation? A classification dispute, a view on whether a supply is exempt, or a credit claim based on a reasonable reading of the law is not evasion. Where the position taken was arguable, and especially where there were conflicting rulings at the time, the extended period is difficult to sustain.
- Is the allegation against you, or against your supplier? Findings about a supplier’s fraud are not findings about your knowledge of it.
Structuring the reply
We usually split the reply into two clear parts. The first deals with jurisdiction and limitation: why Section 74 is not attracted on the facts, and therefore why the notice is time-barred. The second deals with the merits, without prejudice to the first. Keeping them separate matters. An officer who rejects the limitation argument will still have to deal with the merits, and an appellate authority reading the file later can see that both points were taken from the start.
Ask for a personal hearing even if one is offered by default, and ask for copies of any documents relied upon in the notice that were not supplied. Notices for older years often rely on enforcement reports or statements that were never shared.
If the order goes against you
Section 75(2) helps here. Where an appellate authority or court finds that the charge of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression is not established for a notice issued under Section 74, the tax is redetermined as if the notice had been issued under Section 73. If the Section 73 deadline has passed, that redetermination leaves nothing to recover. This is why the limitation point must be raised clearly at the reply stage. It is far stronger in appeal when it has been on record from the beginning.
A late notice is worth a careful second look. If you have received a Section 74 or Section 74A notice, send it to us with the returns for that year, and we will tell you whether the extended period holds up.
Related service: GST notices and refunds.
This note reflects the law, rulings and CBIC circulars as of November 2026. It is general information and not advice on any particular case.